Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Who would you choose,..
Portkey forums - Kindred Spirits > > H/H topics that won't die > Other immortal H/H topics
Pages: 1, 2, 3
jackryan411
I don't like Draco/Hermione at all...it just doesn't make sense. They demean each other too often for that. But I understand that you ship H/Hr first so I'll shut up!
DreamerBlue
Neville would be an OK choice for Hermione if it never happens between her and Harry. And Luna for Harry just because she's cool and thats shes my twin sister. JKR stole her from me. Yeah and Snape would also be a good choice for Hermione ::snorts:: ::screams while trying to duck from flying tomatoes:: ! biggrin.gif

Jess~
Facade
I guess ship like D/G D/HR SS/HR, are guilty pleasures for people.

I can't say they are mine, though.
WonkyKris
QUOTE (jackryan411 @ Oct 11 2003, 10:19 PM)
I don't like Draco/Hermione at all...it just doesn't make sense. They demean each other too often for that. But I understand that you ship H/Hr first so I'll shut up!

Yea I know it doesn't make sense and that it won't happen. Actually, I think it would be kinda funny if it happened (in a sad way of course).

Yay my 100 post! Took me long enough. tongue.gif
Stncold
For Hermione i accidently voted Viktor when i meant Neville, but i guess Vicky would be ok also.If r/hr happens then i wouldnt be as bothered as i should be anymore since ive already done all my crazy outbursts and denial about it already, of course id be sad for no h/hr and go into denial again for a short time and indulge myself in h/hr fics, but if it happens what can i do about it so ive already prepared myself, however some r/hr shippers bother me to no end though, like the whole fanon thing in my sig and saying r/hr is canon already, among other things.

ok, calming now. anyway, d/hr doesnt bother me either, its just that im a rabid obsessive-compulsive d/g freak and my rabid obsessive-compulsiveness for d/g is only topped by my rabid obsessive-compulsiveness for h/hr.

For Harry id say Luna, for some weird reason r/hr and h/g seperately do not bother me at all but the very idea of OBHWF irks me to no end i think i will explode. But as said, h/g solo does not bother me, but id rather Luna because of the above mentioned rabid obsessive-compulsiveness concerning d/g.
jackryan411
Yes, Luna is probably the distant second best choice for Harry and Neville the distant second best choice for Hermione. Maybe that's why some people ship Neville/Luna...? (I don't.)
Stncold
Well as of today i have gone over to the N/LL side officially, however my choice for Harry being with Luna remains the same, because well my D/G ness overules my N/LL ness and i really dont see any other option for Harry besides Hr,G or LL.

Choice still remains as Vicky or Neville for Hermione.

As for my final decision on N/LL, well i just believe they would actually make a cute couple, like H/Hr and D/G.
I feel bad not having an official ship for Ron though(Im not a Ron hater, i see him and Ginny as the new main comic relief with Gred and Forge gone from Hogwarts)
I guess if i had to choose anyone for Ron now id take Lavender though.

As for why i see N/LL as a cute couple, that will be sorta shown in my upcoming post Hogwarts fic that has H/Hr, D/G, R/Lav,N/LL and tonks/lupin.

Of course H/Hr will be the main ship and majority of it will take place in H/Hrs house, however the other ships will be a part of it since it involves watching a Quidditch match.
jackryan411
Shrug...I'd rather see Neville with Ginny and Ron with Luna but that's just me. I don't mind N/Lu though. Whenever you post up that story, please send me a link!
Maru1026
i voted for D/Hr as my second choice..Hr/V jsut..i jsut dont see it
Hr/R- i'd kill my self!!!
Hr/N i odnt see it either!


Hermione wiht the weasley twins...thats jsut not right...that like...daitng your distant cousin...or long lost borthers...
jackryan411
Yeah Hermione with the Weasley twins is just WEIRD. Extremely strange...D/Hr is messed up too, but I think I've stated my views on that already.
Kalie
Well, I personally don't mind R/Hr or H/G. I just don't prefer them over other ships, such as H/Hr. However, as someone mentioned earlier, Harry still thinks of Ginny as Ron's little sister. In OotP, he kept refering her to Ron as "your sister." I think that must say something.

As for Neville/Luna...I honestly don't know where this started up. There was little to no interaction between them. Oh well, if you ship it that's fine with me. I just prefer Neville with Ginny, or Hermione if H/Hr doesn't happen.
jackryan411
Unfortunately, I do mind R/Hr and H/G. But hey, I guess it's better to have an open mind like you, Kalie! R/Hr seems like a divorce waiting to happen and so does H/G. Why H/G? Because when a man doesn't pay attention to his wife, bad things happen.
Max
Hmmm...

I want to say Viktor....but there is something about Oliver.

Hermione and Neville is definatley the cutest, but I'm going to go for Hermione and Oliver.
jackryan411
Oliver? Um...I don't see any possibilities except for in the third book where Harry says Wood looked like he could've kissed her. But what do I know? thumbup.gif
Alexandranl
That's an upsetting topic tongue.gif But IF (ooh, ooh, big word!) I had to choose, it'd be Neville/Hr *sigh*
jackryan411
Yeah, this can be pretty upsetting. But I guess we should be prepared. Just in case, I mean. biggrin.gif
Facade
QUOTE (jackryan411 @ Oct 13 2003, 11:17 AM)
Oliver? Um...I don't see any possibilities except for in the third book where Harry says Wood looked like he could've kissed her. But what do I know? thumbup.gif

Yeah, I don't really see Hermione/Oliver.

He'll probably ditch her for a broomstick.

But this is a just in case thread. We need to expect the unexpected.
KaiserDragon
Expecting the unexpected, fine. Expecting the unrealistic... you're pushing the couples there.
Facade
Constant vigilance!

But some of these pairings are a tad unrealistic. But still we have to stay on our guard. smile.gif
KaiserDragon
Constant Vigilance! It's not a phase, it's a way of life!!! And if you want a life to live, you'd do well to adopt it!!!

Arya1's Acceptance of Fate.
Alexandranl
Nothing's unrealistic in JKR universe tongue.gif
Some of these pairings though...umm...not likely, but possible huh.gif

*runs off sobbing hysterically looking for some pumpkin pie*
Kalie
You have to admit, there are far more unrealistic pairings out there. Just check out the FAP Master Ship list for proof.
KaiserDragon
*Hands Alexandranl some pumpkin pie*

There, there, we just need to keep our faith. We have canon evidence and loads of different thing to support us. Some of those couples have to pop out of thin air to happen and JKR is better than that.
Alexandranl
Hehe love the optimism, KaiserDragon! *takes the pie - finally! I was out of the sweets tongue.gif* Ooh there's a thread in which we're considering a therapy session for believers losing their faith wink.gif

ahh getting offtopic.gif YET AGAIN! Anyhow, whichever pairings, I trust JKR...unless she doesn't follow H/Hr, of course *cracks her knuckles*, because Azkaban has some space for evil writers twisted.gif (nah, not really, I wouldn't send her there, maybe just an uncharted island with no humans and many wild animals somewhere in Atlantic biggrin.gif)
jackryan411
By the way Aramas, the Acceptance of Fate is AWESOME! (Good work by Arya1, no?) Anyway, yeah, some pairings can be REALLY unrealistic. For example, the teacher/student ones....
KaiserDragon
*Shudders* Yeah, that's a good example... Some of those are plain out scary.
jackryan411
Yeah...like anyone involving Dumbledore and a younger student freaks me out. Or Snape...heck any of the teachers! It's just something you don't want to imagine.
Laura Laurent
I like the scenario of Hermione with Neville, Harry with Luna, and Ron with Ginny. It's beautiful. But that's only in my dreams...
jackryan411
I thought you were an R/Hr shipper? And Ron with Ginny? Um...no. That's just gross.
Laura Laurent
The thing with me is... I've been really dedicated to HP for a long time... for a while I was TOTALLY a H/Hr shipper.... but quite frankly I just H/Hr-ed out. When it comes to fanfiction and what not, I much prefer slash and wealeycest to even Harry/Ginny or Ron/Hermione, because those stories are always so fantasticly well written that you overlook the fact that genetics are screaming "EWWW!!!"

But I love debating (as long as it's respectful and fun) and in all seriousness, I'm slightly inclined to believe that maybe R/Hr have a better chance at getting together, but mostly I'm up in the air on all that stuff.
jackryan411
That's cool...Weasleycest...lol, you've been going around with that! Welcome to Portkey...*passes slice of pumpkin pie.
KaiserDragon
Weasleycest? That's new... If I have any negative comments, I assure you that I'll keep them to myself. Are they really that well written? Cause' I'm really having a hard time imagining it.

Better accept that pie. Better from him than most here. whistling.gif
jackryan411
Thanks, Aramas...lol....I wonder about the Weasleycest stories. Could they be well-written? I dunno...it'd be hard to imagine. thumbup.gif
Facade
I stumbled upon a Weasleycest( *giggles*) stories. They can either be written remarkably well or be a piece of crap.

And Laura how can you just be H/Hr-ered out!?! *gasps* How is that possible! tongue.gif
Laura Laurent
Well, I was in fifth grade and I was campaigning around, and then these really creepy junior high kids asked me why I was such a freak, and so I went into this big speal about how Harry and Hermione would get together, they beat me up. I'm still not sure why, but it was a scarring experience.
Facade
Oh. My. *huggles Laura*

That is taking shipping to the extremes, or where these people even HP fans? How horrible to go through that. By the way what were you campaigning about?
Laura Laurent
I was campaigning about Harry/Hermione, I don't think they were HP fans, I think they were just empty, egotistical, power driven souls. It hurt, but I'm okay! smile.gif
Stncold
Ouch, must be scarring. My youngest cousin got picked on by some high schoolers for being a HP fan , but little did they know that one of the starting WR of the football team of their school happended to be that persons cousin and an HP fanatic, not to mention that starting WR has a second degree assault charge on his record.

*whistles idly*

On to Weasleycest, meh, nothing wrong with anything, people got their views.
Yea, thats pretty much it.
KaiserDragon
mad2.gif SuperAngry.gif user posted imageuser posted image
*Grumbles*

Stupid, narrow minded, jerks... You were in 5th grade too...
Laura Laurent
Yes, if I could change one thing in this world it would be to make people more tolerant and less impatient.
Alexandranl
QUOTE
Yes, if I could change one thing in this world it would be to make people more tolerant and less impatient.

*tears of joy, standing ovation!*
KaiserDragon
Bravo! Bravo!user posted image

*Throws roses up* user posted image
Laura Laurent
Gee guys, thanks! blushing.gif


Yeah, the truth is beautiful, ain't it?
jackryan411
Bravo, Laura Laurent! thumbup.gif I'm sorry about you getting beat up...that's just cruel. I think we should go find them and beat them up. You'll find that the people here are very friendly (usually!)...I offer my hand in friendship, Laura.
Laura Laurent
Oh! Thank you Jack!

And thank you to everyone else on this site, you guys are awesome for actually not killing my for my er, interesting antics!
Stncold
Hrm Laura where you live, and if you happen to know where those guys live also, lemme know, i wanna show em what happens when they pick on former pumpkinites or whatever, still wrong!, people smaller then them.
Wheres my bat?

ok im a little overemotional when i first wrote this, but yea the offer still stands i think, tho my junky car prob wouldnt make the drive, stupid thing.
Alexandranl
*stands next to Jack, extending the "hand of friendship"*
They're a bunch of little Dudleys anyways, and will soon get their "reward" twisted.gif
Laura Laurent
Thank you all so much. I'm prepared to bet that you lot could take them on without even being there, because those kids are SO incredibly stoned right now.
jackryan411
Lol...I bet we could! thumbup.gif Hey Laura, whenever you want you can PM me, all right? It's always good to make new friends! thumbup.gif
Facade
Karma is not going to be nice to them, I can tell you that.

* follows Jack's example of extending her hand in friendship*
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.