QUICK GUIDE: ~by gal-texter
- Unfamiliar with this forum? Please read Part I ("How to navigate this forum") of this post.
- Want to check if the fic you're thinking of was already recommended?
Go to the new Fic Recs Search Engine aka Recs Engine! - Want to read --or comment on-- an existing recommendation (especially those that aren't on page 1)?
Click on the FicName in the Search Engine. Then hit the "Fic Discussion" forum link.
Part I - How To Navigate This Forum:
~by gal-texter
CASE 1: Do you simply wish to read or add to an existing recommendation?
Perhaps add your own rave reviews or constructive criticisms? Maybe you're the author, and would like to post ___ (take your pick: new URLs, thank you's, replies to your readers, teasers, alerts of chapter updates or sequels)?
THEN reply to the story's recommendation thread.
->Use our Recs Engine -> Click on the FicName
-> Click on the "Fic Discussion Forum" link.
These will take you to the story's thread here in the Recommendations forum. You may reply to threads here, but you cannot open a new one.
CASE 2: Do you want to recommend a story? Maybe plug your own?
THEN please do the following:
STEP 1. Ensure that the fic you have in mind complies with this forum's criteria (in Part II of this post).
STEP 2. (NICE TO DO) Verify that the story was not yet recommended here, by searching for it in the Recs Search Engine.
If you are recommending a sequel or ficlet from an already-recommended series/universe, then please take note of the series' "Series ID Number". You will need it in Step 3.
STEP 3. If the fic meets BOTH steps 1 & 2, then do include it in this forum! Fill up the recommendation template by hitting the Engine's "Add New Rec" link, on the left margin.
[DOHTML]<a name="critrl"></a>[/DOHTML]
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Part II - CRITERIA for Ron/Luna Fanfic Recommendations as of 10Jan2004
*Recommendations Criteria are much less stringent than the Fic Hosting Criteria
~plagiarized by gal-texter from older posts made by Nappa and Thieving Magpie. One phrase shamelessly stolen from Trisha Le Bon.
1. Exposure given to RON/LUNA Ship:
The story has to give substantial exposure to the Ron/Luna pairing. Say, there ought to be some Ron/Luna moment in many chapters, including the final chapter. "Moment" means a scene that will make the Ron/Luna shipper go "squeeeee!", even if they're not yet dating at that point. But they must have gotten together by story's end.
2. SHIP STATUS AT STORY'S END:
Ron/Luna must be together by the end of the story.
You may endorse a work in progress, as long as you are 90% certain it will end in R/LL. Please don't post a story where the author did not even hint at R/LL. Spare your fellow R/LL fans the agony!
If despite all early indications, the story ends with *gasp!* another pairing, then kindly post a notice on THIS thread. The Mods will then move or delete the recommendation.
3. CHARACTER DEATH:
We do not want fics where either Ron or Luna dies, then the other moves on by falling in love with another person.
4. ‘WARNINGS’ Field:
Do indicate the following in the Warnings field of the Recommendation Template.
a. Slash or threesome or moresome. "Slash" means male/male or female/female pairings.
b. Violent or disturbing scenes, like rape, torture or child abuse. Kindly specify if the scenes are mild or graphic.
c. Strong religious overtones. See, Portkeymates come from different religions.
5. ALL RATINGS ALLOWED - *and all the smut-fiends rejoiced*
But do indicate the rating.
6. OTHER SHIPS IN STORY:
ALLOWED:
--Hermione may be paired with others, preferably with Harry, Ron, or Draco (but not all at the same time!) Harry may be paired with other ladies. But these anti-Portkey ships will be allowed only if ALL of the following conditions are met:
----Their presence must be very clearly noted in the recommendation's "Other Ships" field;
----They are given minimal exposure in the story. Their scenes are few, short, and far between;
----They have NO drawn out adult scenes; AND
----They do not contradict the "NOT ALLOWED" items below.
NOT ALLOWED:
--Stories that give substantial exposures to, or make explicit mentions of, or end in:
=>ships that go against Harry / Hermione, except for what's allowed above.
=>ships that go against Lily / James
--Stories that contradict Lily and James as being Harry's parents.
--Romance and/or Sex between a student and a teacher, or a minor and an adult.** (Read details here)
--Pairings involving a non-human being
--Incest
Again, thanks for contributing to this Forum!