Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Book(s) 7: H/H moments -T01
Portkey forums - Kindred Spirits > > H/H topics that won't die > H/H moments in BOOKS 1-7
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4
Stag_Pumpkins_Otter
QUOTE(tigerchic121 @ Jul 21 2007, 08:51 PM) *

Book Version : US
Page : 376/377 (only going to quote the part on 377, b/c it's evil and awesome)
Quote :
QUOTE
“Your mother confessed,” sneered Riddle-Harry, while Riddle Hermione jeered, “that she would have preferred me as a son, would be glad to exchange…”

“Who wouldn’t prefer him, what woman would take you, you are nothing, nothing, nothing to him,”
crooned Riddle-Hermione, and she stretched like a snake and entwined herself around Riddle-Harry, wrapping him in a close embrace: Their lips met.

Reason : Because, if they aren’t evil and decide to leave the scene in, this would make for a Harry/Hermione onscreen kiss, in the movies. True, they wouldn’t be kissing as their in character characters, but still, it would be amazing none the less.


Aha, ENTWINED, very interesting...

Remember that "entwin with somebody" interview? When Jo was asked that what would Hermione see in that mirror?
hg-Omega
QUOTE(bigkisses13 @ Jul 21 2007, 11:46 PM) *

They are meant to get together but this was not their story. This was the story of harry defeating the Dark Lord. So i think that JKR put this in here for us, showing us that this is TRUE LOVE, she just wasn't writing a love story.

I mean our one big moment is more than anything that H/G or R/Hr shared. They love stilled seem so teenage even when they were all grown up. JKR knew what she was doing when writing Harry and Hermione but they were just too great for this series. Their love would have completely overshadowed anything else that happened. But this one scene in Godric's Hollow shows us that there is something there. He did not share the most important moment if his life (going to see his parents grave) with Ginny or even with Ron and Hermione. It was just hermione for a reason.

Book 7 really made me realize how much it WASN'T about Harry's romances, it was about Harry's relationship with the Dark Lord.

You know, you're quite right. Harry Potter books are not romance. I think JKR somehow knows that Harry and Hermione's love is the more mature and true. But she just doesn't want to explore that area because it is too broad and it would bring in a lot of factors.. and like you said, it would overshadow the Harry-Voldemort relationship. But that doesn't mean I'm not upset with the ending!!

QUOTE

I can't imagine reading this to my children and actually say "Harry married Ginny, and Ron married Hermione" then having to explain my kids a concept of true love....and it's difference from marriage?

I had a fleeting thought about it after I finished, you know. I mean, I would want my kids to enjoy the delights of Harry Potter world but I don't want them to get the wrong idea of love and relationships. I can't imagine how I would explain!! online2long.gif

QUOTE
And that's it for my plan of naming my daughter "Hermione"....It wouldn't be the best name...considering this DH...."Jane" perhaps.....one last momento from the Hermione we so loveD

I think, Hermione isn't as bad as she was in HBP but I'm reconsidering my previous thought of naming my daughter Hermione!

QUOTE

JKR should have never written a book she claimed was all about harry possessing love and then not even using anyone's love to defeat voldemort.

That was what I'm thinking. She kept saying love is the power he knows not and Harry has to use love to defeat him. But the word was not even mentioned! I was hoping that before he dueled Voldemort he would think about everyone he loved and who loved him.. like his parents, Sirius, Hermione, Ron and the Weasley. But no... expelliarmus! BANG! And Voldemort's dead.

Anyway, back to the topic.. Favourite moments.. probably already been mentioned by others before but again, the Godric's Hollow scene and "Harry's taster" remark
Sariele
I think this book possibly had the most H/Hr moments out of any HP book, or at least equal to OOTP.

No author writes things like this by accident. I'm hoping that in post-book interviews she explains why she wrote such a wonderful bond between Harry and Hermione yet chose to keep it platonic.

I've had a theory since HBP that perhaps she wanted to be original and write a close, loving relationship between a girl and a boy which remained pure and untainted by sex. If that was really her intention, then she did a splendid job. But if only she would tell us that this was the case!
figo10
QUOTE(Sariele @ Jul 22 2007, 03:53 AM) *

I think this book possibly had the most H/Hr moments out of any HP book, or at least equal to OOTP.



Contrary to the majority here...I actually agree that this book contains the most H/Hr moments of any of the books (maybe even more than OotP!)

Granted that it contained R/Hr, especialy the cliche ending. But the epilogue really reads like it was written waaay before the book was written, the styling seems off as though reading like an earlier PS /CoS JKR.

*Back to the topic* say what you will about JKR dissing us H/Hr shippers etc, but the H/Hr parts of DH are still among the most well written parts of the book.

The scene at the graveyard was so beautiful and the part where she brushes Harry's hair lightly seemed to suggest unmentioned longing, affection and love on Hermione's part.

JKR could easily have written it less shippy but the fact that she wrote it this way seemed to me she wanted to signify the love btw H/Hr. Not romantic love perhaps, but a higher purer type. Somewhat like a Pullman Will/Lyra type if you get my jist.

While the part where Ron abandons the duo seemed to be a build up the case of Ron's loyalty (e.g. he may have left but he would always find his way back...) it also showed Hermione's bond with Harry that she would never leave his side no matter what happened.

The fact is that all the H/G and R/Hr scenes seems to be typical teen/lust romance (the word "love" is never mentioned...even in HBP when Harry dreams about Ginny, it mentioned her declaring his "attraction" for him, never love...one of the reasons I still thot H/Hr would happen). Whereas, love seems to seep out of H/Hr just never mentioned.

So yeah...I would be really interested in what JKR would say about how she wrote and why she wrote H/Hr the way she did.
Confessa
I never saw any HarryxHermione moments except for one.

Hermione chose to stay with Harry, and not Ron.

For that one moment alone, I can say that HarryxHermione will always be the best couple in Harry Potter.

Go die, Ginny. I was hoping she would fall off a tower.
castsomelight
I don't know if anyone has mentioned this, but there was one moment during the wedding. Hermione turns to Harry and 'beams at him' with 'tears in her eyes.' I just thought it was really sweet. JK Rowling could have taken this opportunity to have R/Hr mooning over eachother again, but instead, she has Hermione turn to Harry. It was nice.
Sariele
QUOTE(numba1weirdo @ Jul 22 2007, 02:06 PM) *

I don't know if anyone has mentioned this, but there was one moment during the wedding. Hermione turns to Harry and 'beams at him' with 'tears in her eyes.' I just thought it was really sweet. JK Rowling could have taken this opportunity to have R/Hr mooning over eachother again, but instead, she has Hermione turn to Harry. It was nice.

I know. I was certain when I read this little bit that things would slowly turn around towards H/Hr.

More fool me.

Why on earth didn't she write, "Harry noticed Hermione beaming at Ron, her eyes swimming with tears..." I mean, romance aside that would have made more sense, since it was Ron's brother who was getting married.

Oh well. As per usual we get the adorable deep moments that apparently have no meaning whatsoever. rolleyes.gif
Tomb84
When I started to read the book, I made sure I wouldn't get my hopes up because in reality I knew it would be r/hr. But I always felt that jkr would include h/hr moments in the book, it has always been more subtle than r/hr, occasional stairs and touches. I remember during the chapter ''the seven potters'' Hermione was already staring at Harry, maybe due to the amount of fear she had as they approached the dangerous task of getting Harry to the burrow, who knows?
QUOTE
Harry caught Hermione’s eye and looked away at once


Ron's insecurity was highlighted early in the book.

QUOTE
Ooh, you look much tastier than Crabbe and giyle, Harry' said Hermione, before catching sight of Ron’s raised eyebrows''


When they arrived at grimmauld place, Ron and Hermione started becoming close again. The part when Harry woke and assumed they had been holding hands!! Obviously Harry as his own insecurities with r/hr, I think deep down he didn't want them to get together, various reasons could point to this assumption. The uncomfortable feeling of having your two best friends being romantically involved or the fact he may love Hermione himself but sees her as out of bounds.


When they arrived in the countryside, I felt Ron and Hermione would come together. Why not? Ron was acting like a child!! The feeling I always got with h/hr, was that Hermione was scared of confronting her feelings for Harry, the emotional baggage that came with knowing Harry potter was enough, let alone falling in love with Harry potter.

The chapter ''goblins revenge'' was pivotal, Ron was clearly not up to the task, he left and expected Hermione to come with him, she didn't and Ron’s insecurities heightened at this point.
My excitement during the next chapter was immense, I really believed Harry and Hermione would acknowledge there love for each other, even if it was only a soul-mate based love, I still felt that they would at least discuss there friendship more deeply and look into the reasons why Ron left.

QUOTE
Harry, I think it's Christmas eve!


Though not a massive shipping moment, I love that quote, it felt like a prelude to something special, they were alone, godric's hollow, it was xmas eve. Hermione was clearly sensing how he was feeling, as mentioned soon after. I was so happy reading this chapter, Hermione had seemed to forget about Ron for a while and they seemed as one. The next few pages were some of the most beautiful Harry Hermione moments, they were totally in tune with each other, physically and mentally. I was hoping for a kiss.....just one.....then she could run of into the sunset with weasly.


Ron's re-appearance was a blessing in disguise......well it could of been. I hoped that Ron would see what was going on between Harry and Hermione. The riddle/hermione-riddle/harry moment didn't really have much significance IMO, it only highlighted Ron’s already obvious insecurity. It did however give Harry the chance to maybe...make a claim to Hermione and admit his feelings for her Hermione.

QUOTE
'She's like my sister'


Why Harry? I would have preferred Ron to have taken this to Hermione and we would see Hermione explain her true feelings for Harry. It was always the same thought out the books, how run was feeling, never hearing Hermione’s version. It would have been excellent if the three of them acknowledged the situation.
Ravenclaw(d69)
QUOTE
She hesitated but recognized the dismissal. She picked up the book and then walked back past him into the tent, but as she did s, she brushed the top of his head lightly with her hand. He closed his eyes at her touch...



Possibly my favorite part of the book... I was so sure this meant hope for H/HR but it didnt. Oh well, It could have been worse couldnt it? She could have written the whole book without H/HR and I would have died....but she did write the most romantic scenes in the book for Harry and Hermione. For that i'm forever grateful.

P.S- I cant believe how people are so caught up about this Evil!Kiss thing. It was horrible. My heart tottaly went out for Ron right there it was just heartbreak for him! I wish they had just left that bit out...Its cruel...
red_samurai21
QUOTE(Stag_Pumpkins_Otter @ Jul 22 2007, 06:49 PM) *

QUOTE(tigerchic121 @ Jul 21 2007, 08:51 PM) *

Book Version : US
Page : 376/377 (only going to quote the part on 377, b/c it's evil and awesome)
Quote :
QUOTE
“Your mother confessed,” sneered Riddle-Harry, while Riddle Hermione jeered, “that she would have preferred me as a son, would be glad to exchange…”

“Who wouldn’t prefer him, what woman would take you, you are nothing, nothing, nothing to him,”
crooned Riddle-Hermione, and she stretched like a snake and entwined herself around Riddle-Harry, wrapping him in a close embrace: Their lips met.

Reason : Because, if they aren’t evil and decide to leave the scene in, this would make for a Harry/Hermione onscreen kiss, in the movies. True, they wouldn’t be kissing as their in character characters, but still, it would be amazing none the less.


Aha, ENTWINED, very interesting...

Remember that "entwin with somebody" interview? When Jo was asked that what would Hermione see in that mirror?


ah, someone's already beaten me to it! tongue.gif maybe this is all some clever ruse... with all this harry jealousy going around, i'm pretty sure jk knew what she was doing when she wrote all those beautiful scenes (hermione brushing her hand over harry's head gives me killer bees wub.gif ). maybe she didn't end it the way it was SUPPOSED to end, maybe she just did so to leave the figuring out to us... maybe the end is not really the end...

still... it was a badly written end...
xoapadani
i like the GH scene and the tasty comment... and tads and bits of hand holding but the ending got to me... i mean they don't really mention harry and hermione noticing eachothers presence
Percy
On top of most of those mentioned, a small one for me is when Harry is willing to keep eating Hermione's mushroom stew while Ron gives up on it pretty much straight away
Miss Mady
Closing this thread as it's becoming too long. You can find the new thread here and a similar topic here.

This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.