Yes! I am bumping this now, so more people will see it!
I think its a GOOD clue!
Lookie lookie everyone! Cool clue here!
Lookie lookie!
(sorry for the nonsense post, I just want MORE people to see)
~*Amanda
Full Version: Book(s) 5: Hermione's reactions to Harry/Cho
I hadn't thought about that!!!!!!1 I glad people always does that!!! Brilliant thing!!
That gives me some more hope about this thing!!!!!
That gives me some more hope about this thing!!!!!
Nice spotting 
I wonder how Cho felt after that!! She's probably
while Harry and Hermione fall in 
I wonder how Cho felt after that!! She's probably
while Harry and Hermione fall in
::Sigh::
Here's another one, but I think I'm grasping for straws:
| QUOTE |
| "Hi Harry," Said a voice behind him.He turned around and found Cho standing there. "Oh," said Harry as his stomach leapt uncomfortably, "Hi," "We'll be in the library, Harry," said Hermione firmly as she seized Ron above the elbow and dragged him off towards the marble staircase. "So, have a good Christmas?" Said Cho. |
Occlumency Pg 466 Uk version
Well, what I got out of this scene was:
1. See how Hermione firmly says she'll be in the library?-She's either pushing Ron into going or to get Harry out of his trance/stomach learch obout Cho. I think the first one is more likley but oh well.
2.We already know this, but see how Cho starts the conversation first? She is starting to get a bit jealous here of Hermione before it really builds up at the end of the book. But Cho has obiously noticed that Hermione has been with Harry ALL THE TIME. Whenever she talks to him-except on his way to Occlumency (but that doesent count because Hermione wasnt allowed to come) she was there! Most people aren't stupid about love-except Harry and Hermione, notice each other dammit!
And after this sentance:
Well, what I got out of this scene was:
1. See how Hermione firmly says she'll be in the library?-She's either pushing Ron into going or to get Harry out of his trance/stomach learch obout Cho. I think the first one is more likley but oh well.
2.We already know this, but see how Cho starts the conversation first? She is starting to get a bit jealous here of Hermione before it really builds up at the end of the book. But Cho has obiously noticed that Hermione has been with Harry ALL THE TIME. Whenever she talks to him-except on his way to Occlumency (but that doesent count because Hermione wasnt allowed to come) she was there! Most people aren't stupid about love-except Harry and Hermione, notice each other dammit!
And after this sentance:
| QUOTE |
| He virtually bounced off to the library to pick up Ron and Hermione before their afternoon lessons. By six o'clock that evening,- |
It just cuts off, not mentioning Ron and Hermione asking what Cho wanted. Now Hermione already knows about the kiss, and we can be right to assume that Ron asked Harry about Cho, was hermione trying to block Harry and Cho out of her head? But she was listening to the date conversation because of the interview plans they made for Hogsmede. Hmm........sounds interesting doesn't it?
I think i'm grasping here but tell me what you think
Marshmallow
It seems that Hermione is trying to control her jealousy so she won't go off chasing Cho around trying to hex her @$$ off. 
marshmallow.. you might be grasping a bit! I like the last clue though..
| QUOTE |
| It seems that Hermione is trying to control her jealousy so she won't go off chasing Cho around trying to hex her @$$ off. |
I wish! Cho is such an evil, annoying, fake little girl.
Murgh I greatly dislike her..
Poor Harry!
~*Amanda
Argh...I dislike Cho as well. It's kind of weird because every time someone does one of these, I say I saw that when I read it. And I have. Same with this one...I noticed it. Of course, every time Hermione was mentioned, I'd perk up to try and find clues...lol, I'm too careful... 
I don't like cho..... she's like this very insensitive person.... i mean she's supposed to be smart, right? (she's from ravenclaw for crying out loud) and being smart could also include being able to read people's emotions
i dont like the b**** either... her!! eurgh!
her!! eurgh!
hehehe... nobody likes her.. serves her right for tormenting Harry
Yes, our poor Harry--
I dont think ANYONE likes her anymore. I mean, after OotP she is just like the least favourite character by everyone.. I know she's on my least-favourite list! haha!
~*Amanda
I dont think ANYONE likes her anymore. I mean, after OotP she is just like the least favourite character by everyone.. I know she's on my least-favourite list! haha!
~*Amanda
Cho, yup she's a goner. I've run into the occasional H/C shipper on the official HP boards, but even they are weak and feeble about that relationship...She's definitely my second least-favorite good guy (Ginny's the worst.)
The first time I read it I thought she was just make sure Harry knew what time it was and everything, but then when I read through it again, I thought maybe she was trying to break the conversation. I hope that she was trying to break it off because that would mean that she was jealous!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Yeah, ever since I joined this site, every time Harry and Hermione are mentioned with each other, I'm looking all over the possibly shippy moments. It's pretty sad.
LOL yeah I know what you mean..
I'm reading my first harry potter book since ive become a hopeless h/hr shipper, (GoF) and I must say, its sad how I keep looking for clues.
And then I bookmark them thinking, 'Wow!! this is a good clue!"
but then later I go back, and see that it wasnt that great..
lol I get over-enthusiastic, when it comes to H/Hr... I honestly think its a disease!
~*Amanda
I'm reading my first harry potter book since ive become a hopeless h/hr shipper, (GoF) and I must say, its sad how I keep looking for clues.
And then I bookmark them thinking, 'Wow!! this is a good clue!"
but then later I go back, and see that it wasnt that great..
lol I get over-enthusiastic, when it comes to H/Hr... I honestly think its a disease!
~*Amanda
Yes, maybe so...but it's a good disease! I personally am very glad I'm afflicted with Pumpkin-itis...
I personally am very glad I'm afflicted with Pumpkin-itis...
LOL your right.. it is a good disease..
I'd rather have this then the flu, thats for sure!!!
(although this DOES take up a lot of time.. ah well!)
~*Amanda
I'd rather have this then the flu, thats for sure!!!
(although this DOES take up a lot of time.. ah well!)
~*Amanda
hey... it's nice feeling being a hopeful specally if you a lot of things to back those hopes up...
WOW i Never picked that one up, Well done Nice looking 
What a Legend making ur 100th post
Much Luv,
~*Jaz*~
What a Legend making ur 100th post
Much Luv,
~*Jaz*~
| QUOTE |
| 1. See how Hermione firmly says she'll be in the library?-She's either pushing Ron into going or to get Harry out of his trance/stomach learch obout Cho. I think the first one is more likley but oh well. |
I'm betting on the first one too because she snapped at Ron when he ruined Harry and Cho's first encounter. Also, that it a great observation Marshmallow, but I think that Hermione was just worried because she didn't want to be caught by Filch after hours. She also didn't seem to be bugged by the fact that Cho and Harry kissed. If she truely was jealous of Cho (and since Hermione doesn't care about her looks etc, why would she be?), then why would she have snapped at Ron for screwing up Harry and Cho's discussion by asking why she supported the Tornadoes? It just seems so unlikely that Hermione of all people would be jealous. It seemed to me that she was trying to encourage a Harry/Cho relationship. Just my opinion. Happy 100th Marshmallow!
iS a great observation** stupid typo
| QUOTE |
| If she truely was jealous of Cho (and since Hermione doesn't care about her looks etc, why would she be?), then why would she have snapped at Ron for screwing up Harry and Cho's discussion by asking why she supported the Tornadoes? It just seems so unlikely that Hermione of all people would be jealous. It seemed to me that she was trying to encourage a Harry/Cho relationship |
Okay, now first off, Hermione does care about her looks. If she didn't, why would she go to all the trouble that the Yule Ball caused her? Which plays a big part of the Ron and Hermione fight in my opinion. It wouldn't have been that explosive an arguement if she hadn't dolled herself up so much, catching (and holding) Krum, Ron, and Harry's eye. Ron got jealous because of that. (No, I'm not jumping ships; I do believe that Ron has a thing for Hermione- it's been proven time and time again. I do not however see any evidence of her returning the feelings).
As to that, Hermione was being polite. Besides, that conversation was pretty early in the year, if I remember right, so Hermione probably didn't feel that threatened yet. And yes, she might have been trying to encourage it. I have too, when I felt that maybe I wasn't really in love with my best friend, and it would be healthy if we could both move on. Then I set him up, and it hurts so friggin' bad that I try to break it up. Yes, Hermione is not your typical teenage girl, but she is a girl nonetheless (something Ron was a bit delayed in noticing), meaning it is her perogative to change her mind.
AML
~*kt*~
| QUOTE (xRonAndHerm4Evax @ Aug 28 2003, 12:57 PM) |
| iS a great observation** stupid typo |
u no all u have to do to fix typos is to click the thing that says edit at the top right-hand side of ur post, but it goes away after about a day
| QUOTE |
| She also didn't seem to be bugged by the fact that Cho and Harry kissed. |
Umm you might want to read that part again. After they talked about it, Hermione was distant the whole time.. I'll let someone else evaluate and tell you exactly what happened (im too lazy right now
) but the point is, I think she was bugged.Lalala Only my opinion
~*Amanda
Yes Hermione was definetly annoyed by Harry kissing Cho. She seemed to be a little too emotionless on the subject.... If she hadn't been somewhat aggitated, her response to hearing about Harry and Cho would be a little less tepid.
Sorry if what I said isn't even worth posting, its hard to concentrate when you've got a DUMBASS sitting on the computer next to you yelling over the mic at everybody online.....
Sorry if what I said isn't even worth posting, its hard to concentrate when you've got a DUMBASS sitting on the computer next to you yelling over the mic at everybody online.....
| QUOTE |
| I wish! Cho is such an evil, annoying, fake little girl. |
Too true! She and Umbridge are my least favourite people...
Love Millie
Hermione was distant after that CHo/Harry thing but she eventually had to be there for him.... because no matter how jealous she may be but she's very good at keeping her cool unlike some redhead i know....Her friendship with Harry is very important to her.... some girls are like that.. if they really like someone no matter how silly this may sound they would even encourage that silly boy because she wants him to be happy even if a part of her is saying, 'you know what he'll be a lot happier with you.'
Umbridge and Cho should get together... Don't you think Amanda?? 
Dreamer~
Don't you think Amanda?? Dreamer~
Umbridge and Cho? *gag* That's inspiring SO many unwanted images into my head.
Anyway, nice observation in that first post! I don't think I caught that. And I've must have read OotP a dozen times by now. We always seem to find something new each day.
Anyway, nice observation in that first post! I don't think I caught that. And I've must have read OotP a dozen times by now. We always seem to find something new each day.
LOL umbridge and cho?
Wow, they certainly deserve each other, thats for sure! LOL!
~*Amanda
Wow, they certainly deserve each other, thats for sure! LOL!
~*Amanda
Oh for sure... they're made for each other... OMG, I just thought of a dirty image, ewwww!!! ::Think big wide open spaces... fluffy bunnys... books... harry potter...:: now I feel better
Dreamer~
Dreamer~
| QUOTE (xRonAndHerm4Evax @ Aug 28 2003, 05:56 PM) |
I'm betting on the first one too because she snapped at Ron when he ruined Harry and Cho's first encounter. Also, that it a great observation Marshmallow, but I think that Hermione was just worried because she didn't want to be caught by Filch after hours. She also didn't seem to be bugged by the fact that Cho and Harry kissed. |
Actually she was very 'ticked' off about the H/C kiss. Maybe you should re-read that page again and see the change in her tone. And also there's a very well written essay by Mad Eyed Mike on Hermione's reaction to the kiss.
lots of matrix agents around..... gotta go better find Neo.... yup mad eyed mike make really cool essays and you'll really get your questions answered
Yeah, it was a very cool essay indeed.
I'm glad I brought up the fact that Cho and Umbridge are my least favourite characters, you guys have made me laugh and have brightened my day. Thanks!!
Yes, Hermione was indeed agitated after the kiss scene... I don't think agitated is the word but you all know what I mean!
Oooooh!
Hermione loves Harry! xoxoxoxoxo Hopfully the feelings are returned!!!
Love Millie
I'm glad I brought up the fact that Cho and Umbridge are my least favourite characters, you guys have made me laugh and have brightened my day. Thanks!!
Yes, Hermione was indeed agitated after the kiss scene... I don't think agitated is the word but you all know what I mean!
Oooooh!
Hermione loves Harry! xoxoxoxoxo Hopfully the feelings are returned!!!
Love Millie
| QUOTE |
| The first time I read it I thought she was just make sure Harry knew what time it was and everything, but then when I read through it again, I thought maybe she was trying to break the conversation. I hope that she was trying to break it off because that would mean that she was jealous!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
Well, Sure Hermione is jealous. Think on her relationship with Harry, at first anybody stand her because her brains and bossy actitude, everytime she try to make friends all backfired... then comes Harry and Ron (mostly Harry (all us know it)). They both come along very well ( very very well indeed
) They share a lot of things, both arrived at a new unknowed word from the muggle's without know antything (mm almost, Hermione had "Hogwarts:a History" already under her arms ), both share some fears and begins where the people reject them. Sametime they undestand each other and fit themselves as best friend of the one another. Their relationship grew close and close to be so dearest as we see it.And suddenly Cho appear from under a rock and Harry follow her like a puppy, Hermione just feel like her first year returned to her, that Cho is steal whom is mor3e important to her... Simply, she don't want to lose him.
Is not a romance undergrown, necesaryly. I would be jealous too if a outsider comes and separate my best friend of my side.
Otherwise... I think that that is cute
'cause mean Hermione had strong strong feelings about Harry and is bounded to him. ( Althought it were strict on a friends way... There is a cool cute H/Hr moment )| QUOTE |
| Hermione was distant after that CHo/Harry thing but she eventually had to be there for him.... because no matter how jealous she may be but she's very good at keeping her cool unlike some redhead i know....Her friendship with Harry is very important to her.... some girls are like that.. if they really like someone no matter how silly this may sound they would even encourage that silly boy because she wants him to be happy even if a part of her is saying, 'you know what he'll be a lot happier with you. |
I totally agree, good girls kinds like Hermione minds works like this. Poor thing is like that beautiful lie I'm happy if the one I love is happy don't it?
PS: Sorry for my grammar, I'm not English speaker ( Not writer, too)
You're grammar and english is fine! We understand...
| QUOTE |
| I totally agree, good girls kinds like Hermione minds works like this. Poor thing is like that beautiful lie I'm happy if the one I love is happy don't it? |
you're right...
Love Millie
marshmallow33 yeh..i notice that too..about "Hermione trying to get HARRY'S ATTENTION AWAY FROM CHO" by saying "you know what time is it?
GREAT SPOTTING..
how about when..Hermione told Harry. To met her at Three Bloomstick..and she always knows..that Harry got date w/Cho..and she even insisted of bring her. Why don't Hermione tell Harry..that maybe some other time..to met her. Why she still want him..to met her at sameday..as his date. mmmmmmh??..isn't that weird..too.
GREAT SPOTTING..
how about when..Hermione told Harry. To met her at Three Bloomstick..and she always knows..that Harry got date w/Cho..and she even insisted of bring her. Why don't Hermione tell Harry..that maybe some other time..to met her. Why she still want him..to met her at sameday..as his date. mmmmmmh??..isn't that weird..too.
She is jealous!!! I mean anyone gets jealous with something like that!!! Huh?? No??? Well, maybe its just me then... buut I always try to get the attention back from the guy I like if he is talking to another girl I just can't help it!!
Ohhhh!!!! and now that I'm reading carefully at the posts HarHermlove4ever said something very important!!!!
| QUOTE |
| how about when..Hermione told Harry. To met her at Three Bloomstick..and she always knows..that Harry got date w/Cho..and she even insisted of bring her. Why don't Hermione tell Harry..that maybe some other time..to met her. Why she still want him..to met her at sameday..as his date. mmmmmmh??..isn't that weird..too. |
Yes!!! That's too weird!!! And from another point of view, the H/C date ended H/Hr??? I know they're friends, but can't friends have dates??? All right I'm not making sense as usual!! See you guys!!
QUOTE(marshmallow33 @ Aug 27 2003, 04:29 AM)
was hermione trying to block Harry and Cho out of her head? But she was listening to the date conversation because of the interview plans they made for Hogsmede. Hmm........sounds interesting doesn't it?
I'm hesitant to say that Ron and Harry discussed his upcoming date and that's how Hermione came up with her interview plan. That implies a certain amount of game playing on Hermione's part and I really don't think that she's doing that. It also makes a huge assumption for something that happened "offscreen" (think of the claim by some R/Hrs that Hermione kissed Ron on platform 9 3/4 as well)
I think its more likely that it was simply a coincidence that placed the interview happening on Valentine's day.
What I do think is significant is that JKR kept Ron tied up all day at Quidditch practice. And it would have been easy to hint at Hermione liking Ron even with him being absent. She could have bought him a box of fizzing whizzbies or chocolate frogs and mentioned with a blush that she bought them because he missed out on a Hogsmeade weekend.. . instead nothing.
We do get a sigh from her after saying that Harry was worse than Ron and then amending it to "no, you're not" IMO that means that she thinks that Ron is even more clueless about girls. I think the sigh means one of two things. . its possible it means both -- (1) Ron is not picking on her "I'm not interested in being anything more than a friend" hints and she's not looking forward to having that talk with him. OR (2) he's not picking up on Luna's "I really like you lots" hints.
Hermione dissects the Valentine Date catastrophe AND explains Cho's actions by saying that she was trying to make him jealous to see how much he fancied her (Cho) Harry completely misses the fact that Hermione had just thrown out her own bait with the "you should have told her you think I'm ugly" comment and recieved a postive response with "But I don't think you're ugly" (more positive than Cho's in point of fact)
yeh..that another thing. Why?..did Hermione tell Harry, that she want Harry to know that she is uply..compare to Cho. I mean..if girl like guy...why is she put herself down..in front of guy that she like. or maybe she want Harry to compare..who is prettier. I mean..why do it have to be COMPARE. If Hermione is friend of Harry..she doesn't have to be compare. She doesn't care..if she uply or not..if she is friend of Harry. She just care about Harrys friendship..to her...that it...but she didn't.
The other thing, if Harry like Cho..he would be saying all the nice and sweet thing about her and do anything for her..but he didn't. He keep saying though the book..that he got crush on her..and she is pretty but that is it. He didn't risk is his life to kill 50 foot snake save her, he didn't worried about her when she was frozen in Hospital wing, he didn't hold her hand or hug her...when she is worried, scared, sad or happy. He didn't got sick to his stomach to think of her when she is lying in hospital. If you are boyfriend of Harry, you would be very mad..and dump him. He did all those thing...for Hermione...not Cho or another girl...that came before him. And I sure Hermione will do the same to Harry.
I hope I am making clear sense...
The other thing, if Harry like Cho..he would be saying all the nice and sweet thing about her and do anything for her..but he didn't. He keep saying though the book..that he got crush on her..and she is pretty but that is it. He didn't risk is his life to kill 50 foot snake save her, he didn't worried about her when she was frozen in Hospital wing, he didn't hold her hand or hug her...when she is worried, scared, sad or happy. He didn't got sick to his stomach to think of her when she is lying in hospital. If you are boyfriend of Harry, you would be very mad..and dump him. He did all those thing...for Hermione...not Cho or another girl...that came before him. And I sure Hermione will do the same to Harry.
I hope I am making clear sense...
Melissa627
| QUOTE | ||
Well, what I got out of this scene was: 1. See how Hermione firmly says she'll be in the library?-She's either pushing Ron into going or to get Harry out of his trance/stomach learch obout Cho. I think the first one is more likley but oh well. 2.We already know this, but see how Cho starts the conversation first? She is starting to get a bit jealous here of Hermione before it really builds up at the end of the book. But Cho has obiously noticed that Hermione has been with Harry ALL THE TIME. Whenever she talks to him-except on his way to Occlumency (but that doesent count because Hermione wasnt allowed to come) she was there! Most people aren't stupid about love-except Harry and Hermione, notice each other dammit! |
You're right, I hadn't seen that one either!!! That firmly way, is just like after the H/C kiss, where she is distant and almost cold.
HarHermlove4ever You're sooo right!!!
| QUOTE |
| If Hermione is friend of Harry..she doesn't have to be compare. She doesn't care..if she uply or not..if she is friend of Harry. She just care about Harrys friendship..to her...that it...but she didn't. |
That's right, you don't ask your friends to tell you if you're ugly or not!!!! You're just interested in friendship!!!
And sadly we ladies have a way of putting ourselves down in front of the guys we like...
It's tragic reallly...
Love Millie
It's tragic reallly...
Love Millie
Hear, hear Marshmallow! I do find it interesting that she didn't buy anything for Ronnie...and he was of course tied up with Quidditch ...Great points...
...Great points...
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.