QUOTE(Salamon2 @ Nov 29 2006, 02:57 AM)

QUOTE
O.o where did you find R/Hr shippers who were bombed out by HBP? My best friend is a Heron, and she was doing backflips! I've yet to convert her though, she's a toughie.
Oh I was a R/Hr shipper that was bombed out by HBP. I thought R/Hr would finally get past their bicker-bicker relationship and star appreciating each other more. And then when the FINALLY did, nothing happened. They just stayed friends... nothing else...
Talk about a let down for a R/Hr shipper
Neither helped the other character to grow, as I've posted before, and as is the case with most bickering couples, they help each other grow and learn. Most bickering couples that I've read, in fact every bickering couple I've read have never argued over little things that don't matter. They instead argue over critical issues and eventually see the other person's point of view.
This did not happen with R/Hr. So I went back and reread trying to save R/Hr for myself, only to find Harmony instead.
~Salamon2
That's unbelievable. Wow. I'm so sorry but I never saw that coming. Props to you for that. I've always loved H/Hr but I've grown a fear that R/Hr may happen ever since book 4, which I now think is ridiculous but book 6 threw me off big time.
QUOTE(Arm_Wild @ Nov 30 2006, 12:11 AM)

QUOTE
I think HBP pushed H/Hr up there even further. I would still be happily shipping without doubts if the IoD hadn't come out. Now I have my doubts, but I'm not that worried.
Yes, I feel the same way. HBP is actually a H/Hr friendly book. And I'm saying that UNdelusionally.
The IoD definately gives me doubt, despite my analysis of it and all..... So now I think we have about a 50 percent chance....
The important thing to remember is that JKR is not a perfect writer. Just because H/Hr are the RIGHT SHIP, most mature and developed, doesn't mean she will accordingly put them together. She could just be bad at romance writing eh? Maybe, maybe not.
Immediately after I read HBP, I was a bit sick from the Harry/Ginny scenes, but I was positive about H/Hr in book 7. Then after I read the interview of doom, I was SURE that we had no chance anymore. Then I took a deep breath, calmed down, and wrote my analysis of it to show that we're definately not OVER. So now... I'm at a midway point. I think we have a 50% chance.
Ah sorry lol, why should this whole board have to listen to me spout off about my feelings? *shuts up*
It's alright. I know what you mean. There is so much beauty in our ship and it's a pity that so many people don't see it. After the Iod and the fake spoilers, my certainty was shot but after reading a few posts from my fellow shipmates, my faith was renewed. It was one of the best feelings ever but yeah I'm about 50/50 on it too.