HermPotter69
Jun 26 2003, 02:37 AM
I want to point out Hermione said:
'She cornered you, didn't she?'
Was she ... spying on him? OMG. And how would she guess they kissed? She probably asked it quickly cos she didn't want to sound suspicious to Harry as she already revealed she had seen Cho corner Harry.
briarswt
Jun 26 2003, 04:01 AM
Guys!
I had a thought. You know the dream scene where Harry imagines R/Hr being crowned? LOOK AT HIS REACTION. Our dear boy is JEALOUS TOO! Seems to me his subconsious is working over time and freakign out
Tazz
Jun 26 2003, 02:08 PM
Don't know if this has been posted yet:
Chapter Ten: Luna Lovegood
Page 194
"Tell me, how does it feel being second-best to Weasley, Potter?" Draco asked.
"Shut up, Malfoy," said Hermione sharply.
=============
=============
Why did she react this way to what Draco said? She seemed really eager to stand up for Harry when Ron and Ginny were doing nothing, and even when Harry was perfectly capable of standing up for himself. I don't know if you can take it as a moment though.
Baron
Jun 26 2003, 02:11 PM
| QUOTE (briarswt @ Jun 26 2003, 12:01 PM) |
Guys!
I had a thought. You know the dream scene where Harry imagines R/Hr being crowned? LOOK AT HIS REACTION. Our dear boy is JEALOUS TOO! Seems to me his subconsious is working over time and freakign out |
[| QUOTE |
| B]briarswt- You know the dream scene where Harry imagines R/Hr being crowned? LOOK AT HIS REACTION. Our dear boy is JEALOUS TOO! Seems to me his subconsious is working over time and freakign out [/B] |
What page would that be or chapter?
Erise
Jun 26 2003, 10:49 PM
-practically dies at all the H/Hr moments-
I think all of the H/Hr moments I spotted have already been mentioned, so I shan't repeat them.
I love the Patronus idea! I was wondering why Hermione's Patronus would be an otter... lol, now I know

I think it is really quite evident that Harry and Hermione spend more time together (despite him not being a prefect with Hermione), Harry thinks about Hermione much much more than ever... Even if it's not in the romantic sense, it's still so... -gets a load of warm and fuzzy feelings-
Seems to me like JKR is preparing for H/Hr in the future, no matter what she says in all her interviews (red herrings to throw us off, I hope).
HermioneFanatic84
Jun 27 2003, 07:40 AM
Did anyone notice harry did not protest when cho went all razy on him?
when she says:
"Oh, you'll talk to Hermione Granger!" she said shrilly, her face now shining with tears, and several more kissing couples broke apart to stare. "But you won't talk to me! P- perhaps it would be best if we just...j-just p-paid and you went and met up with Hermione G-Granger, like you obviously want to!"
See? Harry only said it wasn't like that. He didn't say anything about not wanting to meet Hermione. Maybe in his heart, he wanted to stand up for Hermione. you never know. All i know is, when evr harry and cho get in a fgight, I love it!
Starlight623
Jun 27 2003, 07:54 AM
I noticed that too! I was smiling and laughing when Cho got jealous over Hermione. Perhaps everyone sees it
except our crazy kids!
I think it just proves that if they date anyone else, that other partner is going to get upset over the relationship that Harry and Hermione have! So why fight it?

They should just date and fall in love and live happily ever after.
kronic_burn
Jun 27 2003, 08:23 AM
Before that Harry said "Well-I talked about it to Ron AND Hermione, but-" and Cho only pointed out Hermione but not Ron. Makes you wonder, huh.
purple_mud
Jun 27 2003, 08:27 AM
I think I got a really big smile on my face after reading that scene. So true. Harry never corrected Cho, never told her that he'd rather be with Cho than meet up with Hermione.
Someone mentioned this before, I forgot who, but I think it's pretty signficant that Viktor got jealous of Harry and Cho got jealous of Hermione. That would be two people noticing the not so obvious.
And I think even McGongall notices it. I love it that McGonagall knows that Harry listens to Hermione. What was that scene? When Harry first got detention?
Hmmm, be back later... (rushes off to find exact page)
Asriel
Jun 27 2003, 09:52 AM
This is the first year we see Hermione's influence on Harry being much greater than Ron's influence is!
This is also going to make it difficult, if not impossible for Harry to have a relationship with anyone other than Hermione - I'm sorry, but Ginny, as mature as she's become won't stand a chance when Hary gets into one of his moods - and needs only to talk to Hermione. And while it may not effect Ginny the first time, it's going to effext her after a certain number of times!(I am talking about Ginny here because Ron seems hell bent on pushing Ginny and Harry together)
I suspect, Ron and Ginny's going to find out, the hard way, what Viktor and Cho have found already out! Also I suspect Ron's going to have to figure out where his position with Harry and Hermione lie - he's definitely not an equal; he's a sub-ordinate!
Ron's trying to not so subtly trying to push Ginny to Harry, probably in his clumsy attempts at trying to get closer to Hermione - this is going to backfire!
I think that Ron's beginning to see what Mrs. Weasley, Rita Skeeter, Colin Creevey, Viktor Krum and Cho Chang have seen ... and he doesn't like it so he'll handle it in the worst way possible - his jealousy and inexperience will see to it!
And this is the year Harry will need Hermione more than ever, 'cause he's gonna need a shoulder to cry on - and I'm afraid the only shoulder available is going to be Hermione's!
Liz R.
Jun 27 2003, 10:43 AM
I noticed all this as well. I makes me wonder whether or not Ronis going to notice H/HR in time. He just might blunder right into something he can't handle knowing/seeing. Can anyone make heads or tails of my ramblings?
Liz R.
Jun 27 2003, 10:45 AM
one bit of the H/Hr-ness I've always hated is the prospect of jealous!Bitch!Ron! It's not an unlikely occurance if H/Hr happens. That's why we have to hope with all our might for R/LL.
Anime Redneck
Jun 27 2003, 10:47 AM
What about when Umbridge prepares to give harry the crucio. Hermione flips she immediatley comes up with a way to get UMbridge to stop.
Ashes
Jun 27 2003, 11:02 AM
| QUOTE (Anime Redneck @ Jun 27 2003, 06:47 PM) |
| What about when Umbridge prepares to give harry the crucio. Hermione flips she immediatley comes up with a way to get UMbridge to stop. |
That's not romantic, though! That's a FRIENDSHIP instinct! Hell, it's a moral instinct. If I saw someone, or one of my BEST FRIENDS, about to be tortured, I'd scream for the person to stop, too!
PhoenixWriter
Jun 27 2003, 11:04 AM
I wonder How McGonagall did know that Hermione was the one who said that?
I mean she was very far away and I doubt Hermione gos to her and tell her what she told Harry.
HarHermlove4ever
Jun 27 2003, 11:20 AM
Gee..there are alot of harry/hermy moment from this book. I was grinning for one ear to next!!
Well all of my best is all list it on this post. but this one is my special favorite.
When they were going met with Gawp w/Hadgid. It all Harry/hermy. From Harry holding hermy back up..when she bump into hadgid to Hermione glad harry wrist...when she is scared..to harry pulling hermione beyond the tree..when Giant was going to reach for her.
i forgot what chapter that was...or page.
when they are fighting back to back..from the last chapter..it very heroic moment..it just beautiful and brave how these two young lover fight together like there are no toworrow.
Asriel
Jun 27 2003, 11:26 AM
Let's say this, McGonagall knows Hermione - I suspect that she has been mentoring Hermione (as I suspect she had mentored the younger Lily Evans Potter). I think that McGonnagall knows Hermione and Harry better than they know themselves and knows that they'd be perfect together!
| QUOTE |
| one bit of the H/Hr-ness I've always hated is the prospect of jealous!Bitch!Ron! It's not an unlikely occurance if H/Hr happens. |
This is the OBVIOUS occurance of H/Hr - it will happen for some time probably, but it will happen.
Remember, this is not less jealous Ron that you are seeing, Ron is lessjealous because:
1) Viktor Krum isn't in England during book 5 (and)
2) Ron's just been given something that was rightfully Harry's - in other words, this is his opportunity to take the limelight from Harry, he's placated - the jealousy hasn't completely gone away!
The problem with R/Hr is worse - I can see two effects:
1) Harry will withdraw from Ron and Hermione - or Ron will push him away. With Ron's jealousy, it is a possibility!
2) In a worst case scenario, Harry will take out any residual feelings of nastiness on Ginny as I can clearly see Ron trying to "prostitute" Ginny to Harry in exchange for access to Hermione.
Kalie
Jun 27 2003, 11:30 AM
Nice thoughts, reader! I'd have to agree with you on them. With H/Hr or R/Hr, we'll still have to deal with Ron's jealousy. That's almost a given.
Srox4690
Jun 27 2003, 12:53 PM
I totally noticed all of these things! The one thing that made me so happy was when Hermione says that Harry should of told Cho also how ugly he thought she was. When Harry replies, but I don't think you ugly, my heart melted! Its just a matter of time before they both realize they are meant for eachother! :thumbup:
angel1731
Jun 27 2003, 07:53 PM
| QUOTE (thereader @ Jun 27 2003, 07:26 PM) |
| 2) In a worst case scenario, Harry will take out any residual feelings of nastiness on Ginny as I can clearly see Ron trying to "prostitute" Ginny to Harry in exchange for access to Hermione. |
I think we did actually start to see something along these lines (Ron pushing Ginny towards Harry) at the end of OotP. I can't remember the exact lines or anything, but Ron says something like "Well, choose someone better next time" and looks meaningfully at Harry. For some reason, this part just stood out to me as forshadowing something along the lines the Reader mentioned.
Melissa627
Jun 27 2003, 09:16 PM
| QUOTE (thereader @ Jun 27 2003, 05:52 PM) |
This is the first year we see Hermione's influence on Harry being much greater than Ron's influence is!
This is also going to make it difficult, if not impossible for Harry to have a relationship with anyone other than Hermione - I'm sorry, but Ginny, as mature as she's become won't stand a chance when Hary gets into one of his moods - and needs only to talk to Hermione. And while it may not effect Ginny the first time, it's going to effext her after a certain number of times!(I am talking about Ginny here because Ron seems hell bent on pushing Ginny and Harry together)
I suspect, Ron and Ginny's going to find out, the hard way, what Viktor and Cho have found already out! Also I suspect Ron's going to have to figure out where his position with Harry and Hermione lie - he's definitely not an equal; he's a sub-ordinate!
Ron's trying to not so subtly trying to push Ginny to Harry, probably in his clumsy attempts at trying to get closer to Hermione - this is going to backfire!
I think that Ron's beginning to see what Mrs. Weasley, Rita Skeeter, Colin Creevey, Viktor Krum and Cho Chang have seen ... and he doesn't like it so he'll handle it in the worst way possible - his jealousy and inexperience will see to it!
And this is the year Harry will need Hermione more than ever, 'cause he's gonna need a shoulder to cry on - and I'm afraid the only shoulder available is going to be Hermione's! |
Oh good point.
It also helped that they were together quite a bit throughout this book.
pompom7
Jun 28 2003, 02:00 AM

Holy moly Pumpkin Pie!!!
I knew that OotP had a lot of H/Hr... but no THIS much!!! Wow wow wow!!! Great going, my fellow H/Hrs!! We've ( or should i say 'you've') gathered a huge collection of clues!!!! OotP has the MOST H/Hr clues ever!!! And this is the time it starts to matter!! Eeeek

My sis is reading our copy of the book, but as soooooon as I get it back, I'm gonna check out all these funky references and see what else i can find!!! U noe what, sum1 here shud rite a whole essay on the 5th book clues, or just gather up all the clues we already have and post them up.. it'll be a great way to keep our H/Hr spirits up!! I'd luv to do it.. but i'm not sure if I have enuf time... I know that it's been dun for the other book.. at sum pumpkin pie website... hmm.. lemme find the link..Here it is:
Pumpkin pie.org (h/hr essays)Well then, i'll best be off! Keep on searching for those H/Hr clues, with our eager h/hr noses, we're sure to find some more!!!
Pom
erroom_potter
Jun 29 2003, 09:09 AM
this H/H moment ? but don't understand what it's mean
CHAPTER TWENTY-FOUR Occlumency
| QUOTE |
| . . . Hermione was lying in the hospital wing, her face covered with thick black hair . . . |
what harry doing?
Undomiel
Jun 29 2003, 09:27 AM
| QUOTE |
| . . . Hermione was lying in the hospital wing, her face covered with thick black hair . . . |
Lol! Harry's just remembering Hermione from Chamber of Secrets, when the Polyjuice Potion went wrong
Still, I think it's cute that she turns up in his thoughts anyway...
Undomiel
research_dome
Jun 29 2003, 10:42 AM
| QUOTE |
| QUOTE | | . . . Hermione was lying in the hospital wing, her face covered with thick black hair . . . |
|
Oh for goodness sake!!! LOL!!
HarHermlove4ever
Jun 29 2003, 11:58 AM
I got more of Harry/Hermione moment from Ootp.
"Did you get it" saying very excited hermione holding letter in front of Harry
"me too" I got my prefect badge screaming excited to harry
"It not me" said Harry "giving back badge back to Ron"
"ohh..." said very flowning Hermione "i thought"...
"ron?" ooh..that "great"
(i hope that is right statement) I loved how Hermione get so excited that she "Think" harry got "prefect badge with her" but then..she found out it was Ron.
Arian
Jun 29 2003, 08:10 PM
Okay, I'm gonna attempt to put in my two cents about the possible jealousy felt by Hermione during Harry's discussion with her and Ron about kissing Cho.
Hermione knows right away what happened, and it seems like she's been watching Harry and Cho and their behavior around each other for ages because, when Harry comes in disoriented, she starts right off the bat with "Is it Cho?" Of course she's right, and she says it in a "businesslike way." That's just Hermione. She wants to get to the bottom of this situation because, as intuitive as she is, she knows exactly what happened, and it doesn't seem like she's happy about it one bit.
"Did you kiss?" asked Hermione briskly." Again, "briskly" doesn't imply that she's happy about the situation. When I think about brisk, in this context, I think "cool" or "sharp". Not exactly positive connotations. I think veiled jealousy.
Notice how after Harry admits that he and Cho kissed, Ron's all whooping and hollering but Hermione doesn't pipe up again until she tells Harry "Of course you're not" in reference to his liplocking skills. She says this absently, having buried her head back in the parchment, clearly indicating, at least to me, that she's a little frustrated and preoccupied with the thought of Harry and Cho together. Then she goes on to say that she's seen Cho crying a lot which means that she's been keeping a pretty close eye on her, despite the fact that Cho is a Ravenclaw and older than them and they wouldn't necessarily be spending a whole lot of time together in the first place.
When I read her explanation of Cho's feelings, I kind of got the impression that she may be thinking of her own situation with Harry and Ron. "Then I expect she's feeling confused because she liked Cedric and now she likes Harry, and she can't work out who she likes best" Notice the shift in tense. Cedric is dead; why would Cho be worrying about who she "likes" best if Cedric is out of the picture. Perhaps Hermione is speaking of her own situation in being caught between her feelings for Harry and Ron's obvious feelings for her. "Then she'll be feeling guilty, thinking it's an insult to Cedric's memory to be kissing Harry at all, and she'll be worrying about what everyone else might say about her if she starts going out with Harry." Hermione may be venting frustration about feeling guilty about her feelings for Harry, while knowing that their other best friend has feelings for her, and she already knows that she should be worried about what people would say about her if she were to date Harry because of the Rita Skeeter episode, and because of Ron. The biggest thing that threw me was the change in tense, and why Cho would be worried about choosing between a live person and a dead one.
Afterwards, she asks if Harry's going to see Cho again possibly because she wants to know exactly how serious it is, and when he doesn't answer her, she gets distant and starts scribbling her letter again. And the whole "Harry's liked Cho for ages." just reinforces the fact that Hermione pays very close attention to Harry and is very intuitive of his feelings.
Whew, long post. I might be grasping at straws, here...I dunno...
Anyway, that's my two cents!
jackryan411
Jun 29 2003, 10:38 PM
Great points Arian...my brother (an R/H shipper) says he doesn't like how Hermione's always "brisk" and "businesslike." He thinks that she may be hiding feelings for him...
Ariadne
Jun 30 2003, 06:45 AM
does anyone else feel that if it was harry/ginny and hermione/ron we'd just end up with a massive weasley family? hang on have i said this before or am I just getting deja vous?
HarHermlove4ever
Jun 30 2003, 08:21 AM
@Arian: you got very good point...and i feel the same way..as you do. When you said "hermionei s feeling jealous" of Harry's kissing Cho. I was confused from that part where she said "harry, his not bad kisser" how do she know that he is not?..did she dream of kissing him or something. And how?..did Hermione know that Cho was crying all the time. So i think..that Hermione is jealous and..she is observing Harry's love life. She want to make sure that he get right girl..and nobody will come to hurt him. Maybe she is one...who is "right girl" for him. it just that Harry doesn't know it yet.
pnkrkprincess91
Jun 30 2003, 10:04 AM
I completely agree w/ the whole "Krum-and-Cho-know-something-we-don't" thread going around. Its way too true. I LOVE OoTP!!!!!!!
AML
~*kt*~
H/H4Eva
Jun 30 2003, 12:33 PM
I think that Harry and Hermione have alot of chemistry. But it does seem like Ron is very willing to stand up for Hermione. But Harry can't stop thinking about her. And all the clues that lead to H/HR. But I just have to say one thing....If Ron and Hermione get together....then JKR isn't as good a writer as we all thought!!

H/HR 4 Eva and Eva!!
SummrMagic
Jun 30 2003, 02:21 PM
Harry & Hermione definitely have a lot of chemistry. Their whole relationship is based on that. I honestly don't think Ron and Hermione would even be friends if it weren't for Harry. He's what holds them together since they argue so much. Ron's the one that made the comment about her not having any friends, which sent her to the girls bathroom in P/S and Harry was the one who remembered she was missing when the troll was let loose. He's been thinking about her since then, noticing where she is, while Ron is just thick-headed. Not bashing Ron, I love him...just not with Hermione.
And the whole idea about one big happy Weasley family...::shrugs::. I dunno about that. It may make Mrs. Weasley and possibly Ron and Ginny happy, but it makes everything too...perfect, I guess. And I don't think that's what JK has in mind. I think the books are going to be much more angsty before there is any hint of a resolution.
That's my story and I'm sticking to it
HarHermlove4ever
Jun 30 2003, 02:46 PM
that is what i keep..thinking about How "HARRY POTTER" come to be or going to be Greatest-powerful-Wizard of all. Because he got Greatest-powerful-witch-that will always here to protected and see that he is that. That is Hermione. Harry and Hermione has this "special-bond-relationship" that will bring evil down. and make better world to lived in. Or Wizard world.
Arian
Jun 30 2003, 03:40 PM
I think it's really cute that Hermione's the one coaching Harry about girls so that he'll understand his own feelings as well as hers (when the time comes)...and so he'll know what he's doing when *they* get together!
Leli1013
Jun 30 2003, 04:06 PM
OotP is definetly my fav now. Can't wait to show my friend, who's a R/Hr, this. She's always telling me I'm wrong.
SweetSolitude1377
Jun 30 2003, 05:27 PM
Wow... so many hints leaning towards H/Hr. And I thought this book was a definate Hermione/Ron book! Now I'm undecided...
I just wanted to say something about when Harry was going through his memories during Occlumency lessons with Snape. Rowling writes that Harry sees Hermione covered in thick, black hair... well, I know she's refering to when Hermione's face turned into a cat head, but doesn't Harry have thick, black hair a top that lovely head of his? Anyway, it was just a thought.
This thread really made my day!
~Sweet
Erise
Jun 30 2003, 06:51 PM
| QUOTE |
"Harry, yours is OK except for this bit at the end, I think you must have misheard Professor Sinistra, Europa's covered in ice, not mice - Harry?"
- "Percy and Padfoot", page 269, UK version |
And later...
| QUOTE |
Harry was not convinced he had got the names of all Jupiter's moons right, but was at least confident that none of them were inhabited by mice.
- "OWLs", page 632, UK version |
I had to grin at this - Harry does remember what Hermione says most of the time, no?
Xjhoven
Jul 1 2003, 03:52 PM
Wow there's alot of H/Hr I didn't notice originally. I'm re-reading it now and I think I found something that no one's found (I'm not certain)
In Chapter 1: Dudley Demented, page 13 in the Canadian/UK version it says that
| QUOTE |
| Hermione had scribbled I expect we'll be seeing you quite soon inside his birthday card |
Only Hermione's card was the one pointed out as far as him remembering a birthday card. Not Hagrid's, Sirius's or Ron's. Ho ho! Our boy Harry remembers Hermione even when it's only in card form.
Mind you, this could just be nothing but the ramblings of a hopeful H/Hr shipper. Great hopes though!
HarHermlove4ever
Jul 1 2003, 07:46 PM
here is more of Harry/hermione moment:
when she asked only to harry not Ron, "if he can meet her at Three broomstick" even though..she know that Harry have date with Cho..for Valentine's day..he said "i have plan with Cho " and then hermonie answer back "why don't you just bring her too" (if Hermonie knows...that Harry got date....why can hermione told harry maybe next time..to met her..instead she still want harry to met her, even though harry got plan) mmmmh?..maybe she doesn't want harry to have date..with Cho or anyone else..beside her.
"Harry met Hermione ..at Three broomstick..about that interview with Rita Skeeter, and Luna without Cho"
"Hermione threating Rita Skeeter, if she asked about Harry's love life one more time..the deal is off" (why would Hermione have to threating..Skeeter?..if she asked about harry's love life)
"Hermione can feel and sense Harry's emotion..even then..they are not talking. for example..when Draco came in to their compartment from train...Draco said something about why haghid not being hogwarts. Hermione stand up...and close the compartment door roughly..after Draco left...and she suddenly turn around..and look at harry..and she can feel same way as he does.
"Harry tip someone toe...and it was hermione..when they were surround it by Luscius and his deatheather, hermione said in low voice.."what?"
"hermione turn around and asked harry "what should we do now?" when Harry, hermione and Neville were trap in room and on run..from Deatheather". (Why did hermione turn to harry..for plan for getting her out of danger..and not Neville) because she knows..that Harry is one to get her and other out of danger..because he is hero for her.
diam0ndgrrl
Jul 2 2003, 09:50 AM
Wow.. way to go with all these H/Hr moments. I think I found one.. I don't know if anyone's brought it up yet.
page 262, U.S. edition, "Detention With Dolores"
After Hermione says something in the Quibbler wasn't true, Luna gives her a "withering" look and walks away.
| QUOTE |
"D'you mind not offending the only people who believe me?" Harry asked Hermione as they made their way into class. "Oh, for heaven's sake, Harry, you can do better than her," said Hermione. |
I know it's nothing too big. But Hermione seems pretty irritated with Luna alot. And it is true, Luna is one of the only people who supports Harry. Hermione is pretty smart, why *would* she offend one of their only allies?
HarHermlove4ever
Jul 2 2003, 09:16 PM
yeh..I forgot about that part..where Hermione is pretty irriated with Luna...when luna believed in Harry.
it is big thing..(diamondgirl)...because it means..that Hermione is feeling jealous..that there is "another girl" who believed in Harry. and hermione thought that...that she is only one..and she like to keep it that way.
PhoenixBlue
Jul 3 2003, 04:48 AM
There is another scene that made me smile because it is highly un-Hermione like :
It's when Harry returns from a particularely painful detention with Umbridge (I don't remember the exact chapter or page number, sorry) and Hermione, instead of being irritated with Harry because he got detention, actually looks worry and even brew him a potion to calm his pain (aaawww).
Even Harry noticed that it was very unlike Hermione ^^
gal-texter
Jul 3 2003, 07:41 AM
| QUOTE (SummrMagic @ Jun 30 2003, 10:21 PM) |
| Harry & Hermione definitely have a lot of chemistry. I honestly don't think Ron and Hermione would even be friends if it weren't for Harry. |
I totally agree with that.
As for the H/Hr moments in OOTP, my favorite is that "I don't think you're ugly" scene. Thanks to this thread, I can look forward to plenty of H/Hr moments when I re-read the book!
Ariadne
Jul 3 2003, 01:30 PM
I have to say I am most surprised nobody has picked up on this yet, because to be honest I see this as being one of the most important true h/hr moments in the book
| QUOTE |
| Even through his anger and impatience, Harry recognised Hermione's offer to accompany him into umbridge's office as a sign of solidarity and loyalty. |
Hermione knows what Harry is doing is wrong but she sticks by him despite it, Harry has just yelled himself stupid at her but she hasn't stormed off like she would with Ron. What is more, Harry amid him tirade sees this and it moves him because he mutters in what i would imagine as an embarrassed sort of way. Also look at the way they yelled at each other in comparison to the "yule ball argument". Then Ron and Hermione were standing 10 feet apart bellowing, this time Harry and Hermione keep taking paces towards each other whilst bellowing. More importantly though I think that this highlights that Hermione would follow Harry anywhere. Its almost like the charge of the lightbrigade. "not though the soldier knew someone had blundered, there's not to make reply, theirs not to reason why, theirs but to do and die.."
on a lighter note however i did enjoy the bit when luna says "you two must really smell", if we want to grasp at any straws heres a really teensy one to grasp at. Oddly enough it is smell which attracts one person to another, it has something to do with finding out what imune systems are like to choose a mate to have healthy children. I watched it on a programme about senses, it was really weird but totally true. You could find more on the BBC website because it was a BBC programme, but that is one heck of a straw to hold onto if you want one! Of course the line previous to that is probably more important
"I'm not staying behind!" said Hermione furiously.
dreamcatcher_3107
Jul 3 2003, 05:39 PM
Hey! Very nice moments, just read. I'm re-reading the book and this time I'll pay a lot more of attention to the H&Hr bits. My favorite one is the "I don't think you are ugly" and the whole discussion about Harry kissing Cho. If I find any moments, I'll let you know...
diam0ndgrrl
Jul 3 2003, 06:04 PM
I noticed that moment too
Ariadne! Hermione only seems to bend the rules for Harry, and to her... bending the rules is like the 8th deadly sin! That part was so sweet... even through his crazy adolescent anger, Harry saw Hermione's loyalty.
I also thought it was cute when Hermione had that bowl of stuff to sooth Harry's hand. How utterly...understanding! I'll bet
Ginny wouldn't have thought of that. Ha.
These are the caring moments that are going to flash through Harry's head when he comes to realize he loves Hermione!!!
jackryan411
Jul 4 2003, 12:52 AM
| QUOTE (Ariadne @ Jul 3 2003, 09:30 PM) |
I have to say I am most surprised nobody has picked up on this yet, because to be honest I see this as being one of the most important true h/hr moments in the book
"Even through his anger and impatience, Harry recognised Hermione's offer to accompany him into umbridge's office as a sign of solidarity and loyalty."
Hermione knows what Harry is doing is wrong but she sticks by him despite it, Harry has just yelled himself stupid at her but she hasn't stormed off like she would with Ron. What is more, Harry amid him tirade sees this and it moves him because he mutters in what i would imagine as an embarrassed sort of way. Also look at the way they yelled at each other in comparison to the "yule ball argument". Then Ron and Hermione were standing 10 feet apart bellowing, this time Harry and Hermione keep taking paces towards each other whilst bellowing. More importantly though I think that this highlights that Hermione would follow Harry anywhere. Its almost like the charge of the lightbrigade. "not though the soldier knew someone had blundered, there's not to make reply, theirs not to reason why, theirs but to do and die.."
on a lighter note however i did enjoy the bit when luna says "you two must really smell", if we want to grasp at any straws heres a really teensy one to grasp at. Oddly enough it is smell which attracts one person to another, it has something to do with finding out what imune systems are like to choose a mate to have healthy children. I watched it on a programme about senses, it was really weird but totally true. You could find more on the BBC website because it was a BBC programme, but that is one heck of a straw to hold onto if you want one! Of course the line previous to that is probably more important
"I'm not staying behind!" said Hermione furiously. |
Right on Ariadne...I 'gree with everything you said. I also like Hermione saying, "You can do better than her." Think about it. It also relates to Harry's love life. He can do a lot better than Cho---he can get HERMIONE!
HarHermlove4ever
Jul 4 2003, 11:03 AM
@Ariadne: all i have to said is...

what you quote is perfectly H/hermione moment. and I post something..like that Harry/hermione forum.
i don't you guys pick on this..when you read OOTP..but most of time when..Hermione is worried or sad for Harry. she always had some kind of compassion or emotion in her voice or eyes..like little bit of tear or her face crumble up. What i got from i read this book...or how JRowing wrote about Hermione's reaction toward Harry.
HarHermlove4ever
Jul 5 2003, 07:08 PM
thankss...(Jake)
here is more of H/hr moment:
whole of chapter 33 "Fight and Frighten" or (is that title)..when Hermione and harry lead that Pro Umbrigde to the Forbidden Forrest...
Chapter 34 , 35 and 36 heck..most of last of chapter is Harry/hermione moment. because they were grouping together anyway..with/neville...to fight and get away from deathEater, expect for hermione got hit...by curse

but harry save her at end)
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.