Like H/Hr infinity, they are all convincing to me but I voted for Krum and Chang's display of jealousy. I admit that after reading GOF, I was a reluctant H/HR shipper, but I know there's something fishy about Krum being so jealous to Harry and how Hermione behaves and talk about him often.

Then OOTP came out, and the moment where Cho looked at Hermione like she was mad or something during their first DA lesson, I knew it! Like Krum she's jealous of Harry and Hermione very "platonic" (men i love that word) relationship! And as I continue reading the book, I was right.

OOTP made me 99.9% sure about this ship. (there's still 1% doubt in me, because you'll never now Ms. Rowling.. but that's practicaly a 100% already, isn't it?) Ok I think I'm in my hopeless romatic mood again *sigh*

Harmony forever!

hehe. I voted other.

Simply on the basis that I think they are all convincing!

Love Millie

I picked the Grawp scene, but only because that's my favourite scene. I'm gonna go with all of it. It all adds up.

I went with the 12 GP scene since that is my favorite. I can't wait to see Hermione's reaction in the next book when she sees her "Half-Blood Prince" again at the beginning.

I'd say the most convincing evidence is Harry's reaction to Hermione's 'death' in DOM. But then R/Hr can argue that it was because Hermione is his best friend. But I don't think so. That moment right there really got me thinking that it might happen. It boosted up my faith in H/Hr. But then I would say that Hermione's reaction after Harry tells her that Cho kissed him is the most convincing evidence. Her face expressions and the way she spoke during the entire conversation got me thinking, wait, Hermione might like Harry.

I picked the prefect scene! To me, it's soo perfect and the most obvious part where u KNOW about Hermione's feelings for Harry ...Goodshippers have Hermione pining over Ron, dreaming of his reddish ears and freckled nose...yea, **tries to remember scene**

"The door banged open. Hermione came tearing into the room, her cheeks flushing and her hair flying. There was an evelope in her hand.
'Did u get-did u get-?' She spotted the badge in Ron's hand and let out a shriek.
'I knew it!' she said excitedly, brandishing her letter. "Me too Ron, me too!"

Yes, Ron, I'm madly in love with u...I'm so completly crazy about u that I'd rather be back with the devil's snare than with u now...yes, did I cover all the major points?

Right there, is the obvious proof...of H/Hr!

Man, what a vindictive answer on my part...sorry guys, not the best mood...OOOOH, 178 DAYS TILL' THE HALF-BLOOD PRINCE!! Can't wait!

I would have pick all of the choices! But i chose Harry's reaction at the department of mysteries. My second will be Hypogriffs symbolism. Although people tend to look over it, but such a simple symbol could mean a lot, and remember when ron said "scar"let women, it must have meant something too.

oooooooooooh, gooood point! I NEVER EVER THOUGHT ABOUT SCAR-LET WOMEN! Wow...makes u think doesn't it? JK could've used ne word...but that one, ha ha!!

Mod Note: Please do not use netspeak. Not everyone on this site is a native English speaker and so it is very difficult to understand. Heck, as a native English speaker, I sometimes find it hard to understand. ~Jennifer/Hermione's Twin

I ,too, chose the 'Death' scene. Harry is always thinking about Cho and his feelings for her, you finally see some feelings for Hermione. Also the prefect and Cho being jealous was some others. And Harry protecting her from Grawp. It was really hard. I thought they were excellent choices.

I've actually been wondering about the +1 for McGonagall too... What is it referring to anyways?????

As Nielle has told you a few posts below what the +1 for McGonagall means, this is pretty pointless, but what Kath was talking about can be found here. ~Jennifer/Hermione's Twin

Oh really? Boy do I feel sheepish

Like the characters themselves, the items are strongest when paired together than on their own. When put together, the H/Hr evidence overshadows all others.

You know it's funny, when I'm debating with a Hr/R shippers they mention right away how obvious R/Hr really are, then when they read my signature which says R/Hr are red herrings because they are so obvious, they change their minds and say H/Hr are too obvious.
I just dont understand it, they say R/Hr are obvious, but then wonderful points are brought up by H/Hr shippers saying that they are probably red herrings, then R/Hr's say they are subtle.

If Ron acted so dramatically to Hermione's near death, then R/Hr shippers would probably use that as strong evidence.
But no, since this is one of our ships most cinvincing evidence it's thought of as unimportant.
Along with our Krum/Cho jealousy evidence as well.

Thanks Harmione2004, fishtankbabe, Pamina!

I just wish everyone could accept the imagery that JKR worked so hard to give us (especially the ones in this poll) for what it is: beautiful imagery and not simply disregard it, again because their choice of characters are not involved in it.

The more I think about it, the more I agree with an essay by Mad Eye Mike called "I feel sorry for JKR" (not sure if this one is up on PK already), I recomend reading it if you haven't.

EDIT: I've removed some parts of my post and re-posted them in the H/Hr vs. R/Hr + H/G section as they seem to fit there.

Mod Note: The topic is about what you believe the most convincing H/Hr evidence is and why. Not what R/Hr Shippers say in debates. Such discussion will only lead to generalising Non-H/Hr Shippers, and since debate is not allowed in this section, they can't defend themselves. Kindly get back on-topic.

The most conving is the christmas incident. She was the only one to take him out of that room, and he did it immediately. He got surprised when he saw Ron and Ginny in the rrom. So he expected to talk only with her. And why had she been the only to do this? No one tried hard, even the guy that escaped from Azcaban to protector his grandson when he discovered that a traitor was right beside the boy? I think he only wanted to see one person: Hermione.

I went for "other." The scene that will always have first row in my head will be their arms around each other (in their original shapes, of course), first standing at Harrys parents grave, then walking out of there together.

Sigh... and some people wondered why I like H/Hr..

The most convincing moment for me of H/Hr was the prefect badge incident. When Hermione came into Harry's room at the Burrow and saw the badge she was so excited. She was so happy at the thought of being with Harry. Then when it was Ron she was very uncomfortable.

Then Harry was upset that he was not prefect. It was all downhill from there.

But that was my choice for the most convincing moment of H/Hr.

~Rockgod30

I chose other: To me I saw DH as having the most blatant moments. To me it was a tie between Godric's Hollow and the Bonded for Life scene. And the part where Hermione touches his head - it's responded and such strong imagery in GH.

xoxo
Hana

One word - Quidditch. It'd take me too long to explain why, lol, but it all comes down to it.

I picked Hermiones welcoming hug. She always misses Harry so much when they are apart and is thrilled to see him when they meet again.

But to me it's not one single incident that shows how much they mean to each other, it's the combination of all these reasons and so many more.

Personally, I used to be a neutral shipper up until the end of Order of Phoenix. I saw stuff on both sides, even though slowly throughout OoTP I was leaning more toward Harry/Hermione. But by the end, during the DOM scene when Harry thinks Hermione's dead, I was convinced. That was the moment I knew it was H/Hr. Then I reread the books a dozen more times and became even more and more convinced/obsessed with the pairing.

You know I didn't know what to pick. I just didn't think the other choices were the best. But then you reminded me of that scene. Yeah, that one was the best one of all...ironically it came from DH. Aww, I just loved that scene!

So, I also chose other.

Deathly Hallows is for me actually. When Harry and Hermione's relationship became strained on account of Ron's leaving and his "You Choose Him" comment. The uncertainity that was in the air during his absence really cemented it for me. And the following moments like Godrics Hollow and the hand brushed against his head scene. Hey we even got JKR's confirmation on that one.

I picked Buckbeak and the sybolism of the hippogriff, but I should've picked other because what did it for me was the last half of SS. Especially the scene before Harry goes to face Voldemort and Hermione gives him the first hug that he can remember. Then it's all down hill from there.